Is it so bad if Rugby turns into Football?

The new rugby season is a month old, but this is my first blog of the season, so let’s ride my hobby-horse of how rugby is coming to resemble football.
It is because the cry, so often last season, was that rugby was becoming football. Coaches being sacked, the developing transfer market, players talking back to referees, players owning Louis Vuitton manbags. We are all doomed. What has happened to the game? You have heard it all. You know the script.
My continuing message is that this is inevitable. Yes, rugby is following football. Enjoy it. It could be one hell of a ride.
Peter Kenyon was chief executive of Manchester United and then Chelsea and the very reason that he has got into rugby was because he recognised the pattern. “What I saw was a lot of the trends that were starting to come into rugby: player movement, foreign ownership, TV and media rights, reorganisation of the competitions,” he said in a Times interview. “It all resonated with where football had been 20 to 25 years ago. The correlation was really strong.”
Kenyon’s main point is that club rugby is under commercialised. “Rugby went professional and not a lot changed,” he said. “They got full-time salaries, but the environment didn’t change, the sponsorship and TV did not change. The game format did not change. All that happened was the clubs were saddled with huge extra cost.”
I agree. The Premiership, in particular, is a great product but still too much of a hidden secret. Crowds and TV audiences only creep up incrementally. Saracens should be a massive national brand rather than a quiet success story at the foot of the A1.
It has been compared to NFL in the late Seventies: underdeveloped, uncommercial. That is good because what if it could follow the NFL route? Kenyon believes that it can follow in football’s direction: “I think it is poised for the next change. The athletes are serious athletes. The game is well formatted, it’s a really good TV watch. You can have that next lift now.”
There is an occasional feeling around rugby that the good old game is being forced reluctantly into a modern world that looks like football. To hell with that, it is just part of the deal — at least that is Kenyon’s take on a lot of it.
Is a looser player transfer market on the horizon? “For sure. Those shifts — once they start, they just happen.” The rising power of the club game? “Club rugby will become stronger, which is good, and it’s not necessarily at the expense of the international game.” Job security for coaches plummeting as impatient owners search for the winning formula? “Yes, we are all in this world of immediate success, pressure to perform.”
In summary, professionalism brings money that brings conflict. “Yes, that’s the reality. Over the next ten to 15 years, there’s going to be a lot of money.”
Professionalism brings a different type of personality to the game. Again, irreversible, though, in this case, lamentable.
“Some of the player trends are going the same way [as football],” Kenyon says. “That is inevitable. If you are going professional or in an academy from when you are 16 or 18, you get cocooned. Your education is not as wide. You lose that roundness, you lose that sense of reality with the rest of the world.”
Rugby does sometimes teeter dangerously into smugness. “The attitude of: ‘We are the best’ is absolutely wrong,” Kenyon says. He does see rugby’s values being retained: “It is discipline, it is respect; it is those things.”
Clearly rugby has a job to do to retain that. The England football team in Russia showed that professional athletes can emerge from their cocoons and have their followers proud of who they are as well as how they play. As we head to next year’s rugby World Cup, the England team would do well to heed the precedent.
If they do and, better still, if they do well at the World Cup, maybe they can help to inspire the next step change. Kenyon equates rugby to football pre-1992: most owners were wealthy local businessmen, then Gazza cried, Sky TV arrived, and the Premier League was formed — the game exploded.
Just because rugby is where football was then does not necessarily mean that it will follow. Kenyon sees foreign ownership coming into rugby clubs. I am not so sure; I see those local owners still footing a very expensive bill.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s